Musnad al-Tayalisi 1119

أن شعبة وهم في قوله خفض صوته وإنما هو مد صوته حديث سفيان أصح من حديث شعبة في هذا وأخطأ شعبة في مواضع من هذا الحديث فقال

machine translationShuʿbah erred in saying "he lowered his voice"; it is rather "he extended his voice". The ḥadīth of Sufyān is more authentic than the ḥadīth of Shuʿbah in this matter, and Shuʿbah made mistakes in several places in this ḥadīth, so he said: Report a problem

حديث سفيان في هذا أصح أي من حديث شعبة

machine translationThe ḥadīth of Sufyān in this matter is more authentic, that is, than the ḥadīth of Shuʿbah. Report a problem

طعن في حديث شعبة هذا بأنه قد روى عنه خلافه

machine translationHe criticized this ḥadīth of Shuʿbah on the grounds that the opposite has been narrated from him. Report a problem

أجمع الحفاظ على أن شعبة أخطأ

machine translationThe ḥadīth masters (ḥuffāẓ) agreed that Shuʿbah made a mistake. Report a problem

يقال إنه وهم فيه وهو الصواب

machine translationIt is said that he erred in it, and that is the correct view. Report a problem

حديث سفيان أصح من حديث شعبة وأخطأ شعبة في مواضع فقال حجر أبي العنبس وإنما هو حجر بن العنبس ويكنى أبا السكن وزاد فيه علقمة وإنما هو حجر عن أبي وائل وقال خفض بها صوته وإنما هو مد بها صوته

machine translationThe hadith of Sufyān is more authentic than the hadith of Shuʿbah. Shuʿbah made mistakes in several places. He said "Ḥujr Abū al-ʿAnbas", but it is only Ḥujr b. al-ʿAnbas, whose kunyah is Abū al-Sakan. He added ʿAlqamah, but it is only Ḥujr from Abū Wāʾil. And he said "he lowered his voice with it", but it is only "he extended his voice with it". Report a problem

تخطئة مثل شعبة خطأ وكيف وهو أمير المؤمنين في الحديث وقوله هو حجر بن العنبس وليس بأبي العنبس ليس كما قاله بل هو أبو العنبس حجر بن العنبس وجزم به ابن حبان في الثقات فقال كنيته كاسم أبيه وقول محمد يكنى أبا السكن لا ينافي أن تكون كنيته أيضا أبا العنبس لأنه لا مانع أن يكون لشخص كنيتان وقوله وزاد فيه علقمة لا يضر لأن الزيادة من الثقة مقبولة ولا سيما من مثل شعبة وقوله وقال وخفض بها صوته وإنما هو ومد بها صوته

machine translationTo declare a man like Shuʿbah mistaken is itself a mistake, and how could it not be, when he is the Commander of the Believers in ḥadīth. His statement that he is Ḥujr b. al-ʿAnbas and not Abū l-ʿAnbas is not as he said; rather he is Abū l-ʿAnbas Ḥujr b. al-ʿAnbas, and Ibn Ḥibbān asserted this in al-Thiqāt, saying: his kunyah is the same as his father's name. And the statement of Muḥammad that he is called Abū l-Sakan does not contradict his also having the kunyah Abū l-ʿAnbas, since nothing prevents a person from having two kunyahs. As for his statement that he added ʿAlqamah in it, this does no harm, because an addition from a trustworthy (thiqah) narrator is accepted, especially from one like Shuʿbah. And his statement that he said "and he lowered his voice with it", whereas it is rather "and he extended his voice with it". Report a problem

ليس فيه اضطراب بل هى رواية راجحة ردا على الأحناف

machine translationThere is no inconsistency (iḍṭirāb) in it; rather it is the preponderant report, in reply to the Ḥanafīs. Report a problem

صحح حديثه

machine translationHe declared his hadith authentic (ṣaḥḥaḥa). Report a problem

طعن صاحب التنقيح في حديث شعبة هذا بأنه قد روي عنه خلافه كما أخرجه البيهقي في سننه عن أبي الوليد الطيالسي ثنا شعبة عن سلمة بن كهيل سمعت حجرا أبا عنبس يحدث عن وائل الحضرمي أنه صلى خلف النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم فلما قال ولا الضالين قال آمين رافعا بها صوته قال فهذه الرواية توافق رواية سفيان

machine translationThe author of al-Tanqīḥ criticized this ḥadīth of Shuʿbah on the grounds that the opposite has also been narrated from him, as al-Bayhaqī recorded in his Sunan from Abū l-Walīd al-Ṭayālisī: Shuʿbah narrated to us, from Salamah b. Kuhayl: I heard Ḥujr Abū ʿAnbas narrating from Wāʾil al-Ḥaḍramī that he prayed behind the Prophet ﷺ, and when he said "wa lā l-ḍāllīn" he said "Āmīn", raising his voice with it. He said: This narration agrees with the narration of Sufyān. Report a problem

واعلم أن في الحديث علة أخرى ذكرها الترمذي في علله الكبير فقال سألت محمد بن إسماعيل هل سمع علقمة من أبيه فقال إنه ولد بعد موت أبيه لستة أشهر

machine translationKnow that there is another defect (ʿillah) in the hadith, which al-Tirmidhī mentioned in his al-ʿIlal al-Kabīr, saying: I asked Muḥammad b. Ismāʿīl whether ʿAlqamah heard from his father, and he said: He was born six months after his father's death. Report a problem

أخطأ شعبة في مواضع منه

machine translationShuʿbah made mistakes in several places in it. Report a problem